The Cave Where Turtles Die

by B. N. Sullivan

Back in the early 1980s, the famous ocean explorer Captain Jacques Yves Cousteau and his team made their first visit to Sipadan Island, off the coast of Borneo. They made a film about Sipadan, and one of the highlights in that film was an eerie cave in which they found many bones and skeletons of sea turtles. They had never before seen such a sight, and they were puzzled by it. At the time, they theorized that perhaps old sea turtles just went there to die.

Sipadan Turtle CaveAbout a decade after Cousteau's first visit to Sipadan, we went there to dive. We had heard about the legendary turtle cave, and it was one of the things at Sipadan that we wanted to see for ourselves. Since it's a potentially dangerous dive, the Sipadan Turtle Cave is restricted to experienced divers who have had appropriate training, and it is essential to go with a guide who knows the terrain inside the cave. Fortunately, we were able to make arrangements to dive the Sipadan Turtle Cave with a veteran guide who knew the cave well.

As underwater caves go, this one is not particularly deep. The entrance to the cave is in the side of a limestone wall that begins a few meters below the surface and plunges straight down to a depth of about 600 meters (about 2,000 ft.). The mouth of the cave, found at a depth of only 20 meters or so (about 65 ft.), is small and partly disguised by large soft corals.

Just inside the cave's narrow mouth is a fairly roomy chamber, where we paused to let our eyes begin to adjust to the darkness. Once we passed beyond this first chamber there was no ambient light at all, so of course the three of us -- the guide, Jerry, and I -- carried multiple lights with us on this dive.

What makes the dive tricky is the cave's interior terrain - an intricate maze of chambers connected by narrow tunnels. The tunnels are not straight: they curve this way and that -- not just left and right, but also up and down, as if the whole works had been built as a bed for a roller coaster.

The bottom of the entire cave system was covered in fine, silty sand, so we had to be extremely careful to stir it up as little as possible as we went along. Once fine sand gets stirred in small spaces like that, visibility is quickly reduced to zero.

Sipadan Turtle CaveWe saw and photographed the famous turtle skeletons, which we came across in several of the cave's chambers. Some were no more than disorderly piles of bones, like the first photo on this page. Others were more complete skeletons, with half-disintegrated carapaces, and goofy looking turtle skulls, like the second photo. [Click on any of the photos to enlarge.]

While Cousteau and his group conjectured that old or sick turtles may have gone there intentionally to die, our guide told us that Cousteau's original notion had been replaced more recently by a more prosaic explanation: Turtles occasionally wander into the cave system, perhaps to rest, or to hide from a predator, or maybe just out of curiosity. Then they become lost in the dark, disorienting interior of the cave. When they need to surface for a breath of air, they can't find their way out, so they drown. This explanation, while not as romantic as Cousteau's, made sense to us.

Sipadan Turtle CaveTurtles are not the only air breathing animals to have drowned in that cave. In one of the cave's chambers our guide used his light to direct our attention to a rocky ledge. There was the complete skeleton of an unlucky dolphin, which had shared the fate of the hapless turtles.

Diving in the Sipadan Turtle Cave was one of the highlights of our time at that remarkable little island in the Celebes Sea. We recently unearthed a cache of photos from our first trip there -- not just underwater photos, but some taken on the journey there, and on the island. For the next several posts, we will share some of those photos, and the tales that go with them. Stay tuned.

On a collision course with critters in the sea

by B. N. Sullivan

This post was inspired by a comment on our Rush Hour On the Reef photo in which Chris asked, "It's probably a fairly silly question, but do you ever get run into by fish?" The short answer is, "No, not really." But we have had some very close calls.

Little fish, like the fast-swimming Fuslier Fish we showed you recently, often approach in a large school, and at a high rate of speed, but they manage to steer en masse around obstacles -- including divers -- by making high-speed turns in unison, or simply by splitting the school for a moment, with half the fish passing on each side of the diver. Once past the obstacle, the fish reunite into one school again and continue on their way.

Other kinds of small fish that form dense schools do more hovering than swimming around. Sometimes a diver will encounter a dense school of Sweepers or Glassfish hovering in an underwater canyon, or even inside a shipwreck or a cavelet. As the diver (or a large fish) swims toward the apparent wall of little silvery fish, they may scatter. More often, though, the school simply parts like two halves of a stage curtain to allow the bigger swimmer to pass through, then closes again afterward. It can be an amazing sight, and an almost dream-like experience.

In sum, smaller fish usually get out of the way of larger fish and divers, one way or another. Now let's talk about larger fish -- much larger fish.

Whitetip Reef Shark (Triaenodon obesus)Over the years, we have noted that the larger the animal, the more likely it will notice divers and even come close to have a look. On occasion they come very, very close.

Consider the photo at right: that's a Whitetip Reef Shark (Triaenodon obesus). I first saw this particular shark while it was about 75 feet (23 meters) in front of me. It was coming toward me at a leisurely pace, so I settled into position and aimed my camera, hoping it would come close enough for a good photo.

Through the viewfinder I watched it come closer and closer, heading straight at me now. It had spotted me, for sure.

About two seconds before I snapped the shutter for this shot I thought I might have to duck out of the way, because the shark had now picked up speed a bit and I feared it might bump into me, head on. I knew it had seen me, so it was starting to feel like a game of chicken! Then at the last moment, the shark made a sharp right turn directly in front of me and swam off (as if that had always been what it had intended to do!), avoiding a collision.

This was neither the first nor the last time that one of the larger species on the reef had intentionally come right up to one or both of us to look us over, and made a very close pass. In fact, sharks and barracudas often do this. So do large groupers, wrasses, jacks, and every kind of marine mammal we've ever been with in the water, including dolphins and whales. (Long-time readers of The Right Blue will recall our tale of close encounters with humpback whales.) But none of these cases ended in a collision, either.

On the other hand, we've had, or witnessed, quite a number of very close calls -- near-collisions with big critters in the sea. Usually this happens when two critters, or rather a critter and a diver, round a corner or swim over a rise at the same time from opposite directions, unaware that the other is approaching until they nearly collide.

Another scenario for close scrapes occurs when a diver inadvertently startles an animal, and the animal reflexively attempts to escape the scene. Once, while diving with a good friend and a visiting diver, we took the visitor to a place where we knew Whitetip Reef Sharks went to rest. The spot was a sheltered cavelet in the face of an underwater cliff. We approached carefully from below the cavelet and quietly positioned ourselves so that we could peek inside. My friend shined his light onto the ceiling of the cavelet, so that the light reflected down just enough for us to see two sharks 'sleeping' inside. The visitor, wanting to get a better look, shined his light straight into the cave, right into the face of one of the sharks. The shark startled and shot out of the cavelet like a missile, grazing my friend's head on the way, and knocking off his dive mask in the process.

On another occasion, Jerry and I passed below a ledge where drowsy sharks sometimes lolled. I was in the lead, with Jerry following just a meter or two behind me. As best as we can reconstruct what happened, we think my exhaled air bubbles must have passed by a shark on that ledge and disturbed it. It was another 'missile launch' situation, but this time the shark swam between Jerry and me, and as it did, it passed right in front of Jerry's face. Reflexively, Jerry's arms shot forward and he shoved the shark. This shocked the poor shark even more, and it sort of jack-knifed sideways. By this time I had turned around, and now the shark went berserk, probably thinking we were trying to corral it. It swam around frantically in a very tight circle for two or three revolutions (like a puppy chasing its tail) before it saw its opening and catapulted itself from between us and went careening down the reef. We stared after it until we could no longer see it, our hearts pounding from the unexpected excitement on an otherwise tranquil and leisurely dive.

Here's one more photo from a near-collision we had with a large stingray. From a technical point of view, it's a lousy shot, but I'm posting it anyway because it has such an interesting story.

We were on a deep sandslope, where I was shooting macro photos of small creatures that inhabited the nooks and crannies of a large, irregular rock. We were both crouched over the rock, engrossed in the task. Jerry looked up briefly, just in time to see an Amberjack swimming up the slope, heading right toward us. Jerry nudged me and pointed toward the Amberjack. I turned my head to look, and noticed that there was another, darker creature moving along the sand, beneath the Amberjack. In one of those 'lightbulb' moments of comprehension, we instantly recognized that we were witnessing a rare sight: a large deep-dwelling stingray species hardly ever seen by divers. Even though my camera was set up for macro, I whirled around and snapped this one shot, just as the Amberjack veered away, and the stingray sort of skidded to a stop, touching me, but just barely.

What looks like snow in the photo is light from my camera's strobe, reflected on sand particles that the stingray and I had stirred up at that moment. An instant later the big stingray did an urgent about face, stirring up a huge cloud of sand particles as it quickly retreated back to the depths.

In case you are wondering about the stingray, it looked to be about 1 to 1.5 meters across. It is either a Hawaiian Stingray (Dasyatis brevis) or a Brown Stingray (Dasyatis latus), but the photo is not clear enough to determine which it is with certainty. Both are known to inhabit deep sandy areas in Hawaii. They are uncommon around reefs, so they are rarely seen by divers. This was one of only three or four encounters we have had with one of these stingrays in all our years of diving in Hawaii, and this was the only time I got to photograph one.